After petition tops 3,000 signatures, subcommittee plans to recommend saving Lantern Bay Park trees
By CLARA BEARD
After residents rallied against a plan to remove mature trees at Lantern Bay Park, city councilmembers are now reconsidering.
Click on photo for a larger image
Photo by Clara Beard
Pines, initially slated to be removed, line a walkway up to the Marriott at Lantern Bay Park
The city stated in an October 14 project update that a subcommittee, made up of Mayor Pro Tem Mike Frost and Councilmember Matthew Pagano, has held “meaningful discussions” with Marriott leadership and will recommend keeping all the trees. The renovation plan will not be on the City Council’s October 20 agenda.
The update also says a public gathering with the subcommittee is being planned for November 1, at 10:30 a.m. at Lantern Bay Park. The subcommittee’s recommendation is expected to go before the council on November 17.
The shift follows a wave of public opposition to an earlier proposal to remove a grove of Italian stone pines and a row of Torrey pines near the Smyth Brothers Amphitheater. Dana Point resident Gwendolyn Oxenham wrote in the Dana Point Unplugged Facebook group Wednesday that more than 3,000 people had signed a petition in three days.
“This past Saturday, I stood in the shade, meeting strangers who were there for the same reason I was: because they couldn’t stomach losing these trees. We shared memories, told stories, shyly mused about what the pines meant to us and wrote notes to the trees.
“In 3 days, more than 3,000 people signed the petition. We came together as a community in a way that made me feel a kind of hope I hadn’t felt in a long time,” Oxenham wrote.
At the October 6 council meeting, residents filled the chambers to speak against the proposed tree removals. The council’s initial motion to approve the hotel-funded renovation plan failed 3-2. Councilmembers then formed the subcommittee to meet with Marriott representatives and city staff about alternatives that could preserve as many trees as possible.
“The Lantern Bay Park subcommittee, established by the City Council, as well as our councillmembers, are determined to always serve the community first. Our community has been vocal about the future of the park and their input has made our job easy,” Pagano said.
The Marriott’s initial proposal included a botanical garden, new paths, an arbor walk and amphitheater improvements. During the last council meeting, city staff had said the Italian stone pines were healthy but had outgrown their space, while several Torrey pines were in poorer condition. They added at least two Torrey pines need to be removed regardless of the larger project.
The city’s project update is available at www.danapoint.org/parkrenovation.


























































